Dealing With Constructive Criticism

As I come to the close of my masters in fine arts, and my book is almost out in the real world for real-life ripping and shredding by editors, I realize that I have gained at least one major skill over the course of the past decade: thick skin. If you have ever thought about pursuing a career as a musician, painter, writer, or any other type of artist, you assuredly got the questioning look from your parents, and the question "Well, what are you going to do with that anyway?" That was the start of it, that was the birth of the little inkling that is, or will assuredly become, your incredibly think skin. Having enough confidence in yourself to even describe yourself as an artist is incredibly strong, so if you've already done that take solace. As I moved forward through my MFA I realized that not everyone would love my writing quite as much as I, my friends, or my loved ones did. In fact, there were people who literally criticised almost every word I wrote...we're talking about twenty pages per submission, so that's A LOT of critique. But as I moved upward and onwards away from that first fateful "I don't like this," I began to realize that they weren't necessarily attacking me, just like my parents weren't with their original questioning. Instead, these naysayers were trying to help me to develop my piece into a final product. This method of thinking doesn't only apply to creative types, either. It can apply to people writing papers for colleges, reports for the boss, and in any other number of situations. Writing is tough, and if someone criticises you, instead of taking it to heart just take it with a grain of salt and think "Hey, they must really care if they are taking the time to tell me this should be better," and be grateful for what you have been given. After all, chances are they've had rough critiques, too.
Jay Pineda's picture
Jay Pineda
Offline
Junior Contributor L2
Joined: 2011-06-07
take criticism positively

Whatever field of study we choose, or whatever we do, criticism is always there especially when you take a major where they say 'you have no future' I believe that it is an inevitable part of life. But don't frown when I say it is inevitable, because having someone to criticize you all the time is great. Why? because they actually tell the bad sides of your work and which parts you need to improve. Don't take criticisms negatively. Do not be too sensitive on what they say, though most criticisms may sound harsh, criticisms gives you room for improvement, believe it or not. So instead of getting annoyed or angry of criticisms, Why don't you take a pen and list down all the things that they say.  And then afterwards, analyze if they are actually right, if they are right, then make some improvements. But if they are just talking non sense, just take it as a motivation to work harder. Work hard so you can prove to the majority that you are doing good. You don't have to impress your critiques. Don't mind them. Instead of letting them pull you down, take the ma motivation to keep climbing up. Those who succeed are those who listened to sensible criticisms and disregarded the irrelevant ones.

simona-ioana's picture
simona-ioana
Offline
Junior Contributor L1
Joined: 2012-05-06
W have to appreciate
W have to appreciate ourselves in order to be able to advance in our live. We have to be conscious on what level we are and how much higher can we go. We have to listen to all types of criticism, good or bad it does not really matter, and we will have to extract what seems important for us. Negative criticism can also help us, sometimes even more that the good one. If we are not self-conscious we are not able to advance. Criticism does not have to hurt us. We don’t have to take it right in the face. We can avoid criticism but if we do that, nothing good will happen. Even the best of us have been criticized many times before they got the chance to get to the top. If you don’t like the word, you can consider the critics like pieces of advice from people who have been through your situation. I have taken many critics over the ages, but they only acted like an impulse for me. They did not drag me down but they made much stronger. I did not listen to all people who had to say something against me but I listened to those who had only good intentions. Make sure that people don’t want to harm you and only after that listen to what they have to say.
newkid on the block's picture
newkid on the block
Offline
Junior Contributor L1
Joined: 2012-04-20
That's why these days we have
That's why these days we have come up with the word 'constructive criticism since many critics these days are only interested in putting down others and make them feel bad. Getting the ideas of critics and their suggestions is an innate mechanism whereby the human kind can improve themselves. Learning from others experience (which they give others in the name of advice) is the best thing to evolve faster instead of going through the experience by each person everytime.  But this process is can become negative if the critics think that it is an opportunity for them to show how superior they are and how dumb the other person is! Luckily, not all the times critics mean harm and it is upto the person who is the recipient of criticism to be open minded and put to good use the advice received. Parents, friends, siblings and teachers they all mean good will when they offer their advice (which actually is not a criticism) as they feel that you should be the best out there. And people who give the harsh criticism, one should be very thankful to them as they are honest with you and tell you what they think - the toughest teacher is the best teacher and can teach you what real life is!
Kassandra1408's picture
Kassandra1408
Offline
Junior Contributor L1
Joined: 2012-07-18
Criticism
I think that criticism takes many forms. There are insults, plain mean and destructive, lacking any rational thought and purely based on emotions. Then there’s the anger, which might stem from your writings/ actions. A change in approach is advised here. Critiques are actually seldom and valuable. Keep in mind that they are suggestions for amendment, but remember to focus solely on the constructive part, fully ignoring the foul language. You’re old enough to see just how mean people around you can be. But that doesn’t mean you understand it. Try focusing on self improvement for your sake, and don’t let others get to you.  You’re in college to sharpen your skills, bind life-lasting friendships, and explore new paths. Do not let someone else deter you. Learn to be thick skinned. It might go against what you’ve been taught, but trust me, this is a skill worth mastering. Just how exactly can you do that? Avoid provocations, you know how much you’re worth, ignore anyone telling you differently. And don’t take things personally; the whole thing might not be about you. Focus on your goals and on the methods to achieve them, so you don’t dwell too much on your flaws. Try not to be too impulsive, and learn to think twice before you act.  Patience truly is a virtue.
collegegurl's picture
collegegurl
Offline
Charter Member
Joined: 2012-07-21
I'm always so bad at
I'm always so bad at criticism at first but slowly realize that they are correct in time. It's something I have to work on more for sure.